What To Choose: Gas Or Charcoal Grill?

One of the best ways to strengthen your relationship with friends and family is by hosting a dinner party. Gathering everyone over a meal will allow you to enjoy the conversation and the time spent together. In these events, you’ll often find the grill becomes the hub of pre-meal discussion. Everyone can enjoy watching their food get cooked. However, to have the best event, you will need to choose the best grill. In this area, there are two main choices available on the market. Generally, your options are either charcoal or gas. Each of these two cooking methods has both pros and cons. In order to allow you to make a wise purchasing decision, let’s look at some of the elements that you should consider before buying a grill.

Grill Configurations

Though the two main types of grills are gas and charcoal, there are multiple sub-categories. These can often be grouped by the way that they are configured. This might impact on the type of food that you can cook on these grills. By considering the way that you will use the grill, you will be able to choose the best configuration for you.

First, you can choose an open grill. This is one of the simplest ways of cooking food. You have a hotplate single hotplate, which you place the food onto. This is perfect for foods that require high heat to cook. For example, you might use this to cook things like steak or kebabs.

What To Choose: Gas Or Charcoal Grill? 1 - Fire Pits & Grills

Alternatively, you can use a covered grill. This has a lid that you can place over the grill. This will give you more flexibility over how you can cook the food. For example, you might to slowly roast your food at low heat. For this reason, it might be better suited to thicker cuts of meat, which will take a longer time to cook properly.

The third form of grills is rotisserie. This will slowly turn the meat above the grill, making sure that it gets cooked evenly. It will also allow you to create a juicy interior with a crunchy exterior. This is perfect for cooking larger pieces of meat. For example, you might use this for a whole chicken or for cooking a whole hog.

Finally, you might opt to use a smoker. This will feed smoke into the food as it cooks, increasing the amount of flavor that you can infuse into the meat. Generally, this will work better with thicker cuts of meat, like steak. It might also help you dissolve fat, increasing the tenderness of the meat.

The style of cooking that you prefer to use will vary. This might influence the type of grill that you are looking for. You should also note that you might be able to purchase attachments for your grill. This will allow you to increase its versatility, using it for multiple forms of cooking. For example, you might want to purchase a smoker add-on.  Now that we know a little more about the most common grill configurations, let’s look at some of the factors that will influence the grills performance. This will help you determine whether you want a charcoal or gas grill.


The flavor is one of the most important things to consider when deciding which grill to purchase. However, this aspect of the debate tends to be hotly contested. For example, charcoal bricks are able to get hotter. This will make it easier for you to sear meats. In addition, charcoal tends to produce a lot more smoke. In some cases, this can help you infuse more flavor into the meat. However, it will charcoal longer to cool. For this reason, you will have to space out the food on the grill, to allow you to cook at different temperatures. In addition, you might notice some charcoal marks on the food.

If you choose to use gas, you will have more control over the temperatures. This can make it easier for you to cook foods. In addition, gas tends to release more steam. This will lock more moisture in the food. However, this can have an impact on the flavors. For example, some people say it makes the food taste slightly more metallic. While gas doesn’t produce any smoke, you can use a smoker attachment to emulate those flavors.

The taste of food is often very subjective, making it hard to assess which grill type will produce the best flavor. For this reason, you might want to try visiting local grilling restaurants. Pick one that uses charcoal and one that uses gas. Then compare the food produced. This will allow you to get a better indication of which type of food you prefer.

Cooking Time

Slow cooking meat over a grill can be a great way to infuse more flavors into each meal. However, this isn’t always possible. Sometimes you just want to grill up a quick and easy dinner. For this reason, you might want to consider how long it will take for you to cook food on each of these fuels. First gas grills will be able to heat up faster. This will allow you to start cooking quicker. In addition, you will be able to change the temperature faster.

On the other hand, charcoal tends to take a little longer to get hot, as you need to wait for the charcoal to start cooking. However, once it’s hot it will stay hot for longer, though you will need to monitor the cooking temperatures. For this reason, you might be able to cook a quick meal faster on a gas grill.


When you purchase a grill, you should know the circumstances that you want to use it in. For example, some people might want a smaller grill that they can take with them to parties. Others might prefer a larger, stationary grill. However, if you want a portable grill, you might want to choose one that uses charcoal. This type of fuel is very easy to transport and isn’t very heavy. With a gas grill, you will need to bring the gas bottle with you. Depending on the size of the grill, the bottle can be very heavy.


You might also want to think about how easy it will be to set-up each grill. Both of these tend to be very simple. For example, all you need to do is add charcoal or connect the gas bottle. However, you will be able to start cooking on the gas faster. This is because the gas tends to ignite quickly, heating up the plates. A key part of the set-up for charcoal is waiting for the bricks to heat up. To get them lit, some people prefer to use lighter fluid and matches. However, some people claim that this can give the food a slightly metallic taste.

In addition, you will need to have a reliable way of measuring the temperature. You will be able to get a more accurate gauge of temperature with gas grill, as it provides a more consistent form of heating. If you are using charcoal, you will have to rely on thermometers to tell you how hot it is. However, these can be inaccurate. For this reason, you might need to use a kitchen thermometer. This is will allow you to know the internal temperatures of the meat, to make sure that they are cooked properly.


A key part of owning a grill is keeping it in good condition. This will help extend its lifespan and reduce the number of repairs that you need to perform. With each type of grill, there are several maintenance activities that you will need to perform. For example, you might need to clean the grease trap. Generally, though, it’s easier to clean a gas grill. The food tends to come off the racks without much effort. In addition, these units tend to have a removable drip tray. On the other hand, the ash from the charcoal grills can stick to the racks. This can be hard to remove. For this reason, you might have to consider investing in a steamer. By heating up the plates, you will be able to remove food scraps easier. Also, you might need to use a brush, to scrape away any excess foods.


When you are looking for a grill, you will often have a budget that you need to work within. This might limit which type of grill you will be able to purchase. Generally, charcoal doesn’t tend to be as complex as a gas grill. For this reason, gas grills tend to be more expensive. However, there is a range of products available for each of these fuel types. This means that you will be able to find something that will be able to suit your budget.

Running Costs

When you purchase a grill, you might also want to consider what the operating costs will be. In this area, there are multiple factors to consider. First, you might need to consider how much it will cost to have the grill installed. How expensive this will often vary, depending on the type of grill you want to buy. For example, a smaller portable grill has no installation costs. However, if you want a larger grill, you might consider building a platform around it, to create an outdoor kitchen. In addition, some people choose to run a fuel line between the house and a gas grill. This ensures that you won’t run out of fuel. However, this can also be an expensive process. To make sure that it’s been done safely, you should consider hiring a professional to take care of it for you.

You should also think about how much it will cost to purchase the fuel. Gas tends to be slightly more expensive than charcoal, as the price changes more frequently. However, they are both available in abundance. This means that you will be able to take your grill on holidays, without having to worry about whether you will be able to find more fuel.

Another important area to consider is how often you will need to perform repairs. This will vary, depending on the way that you use the grill. Generally, you will need to pay more to maintain a repair a gas grill. This type tends to have more components, which can break off or get damaged. To ensure that everything is fixed properly, you will need to call in a professional to perform the repairs for you.


When you own any type of appliance, you want to make sure that it’s safe. This is especially true for cooking equipment which, if it malfunctions, can do serious damage. Thankfully, both of these types of grills are extremely safe, as long as you use them properly. It should be noted that you might need to monitor charcoal more closely than gas. Because these grills can get very hot, they can be a potential hazard if they accidentally get tipped or knocked over. You might also need to have a bucket nearby, as a safety precaution.


You might also want to think about the number of attachments that you can purchase. While these aren’t necessary for basic cooking, they can help you add in more flavors and make it easier for you to produce food. For example, a smoker will allow you to infuse more flavor into food. Alternatively, a cover for your grill can make it easier for you to slow cook food. Generally, you will be able to find more add-ons for gas grills. In some cases, you might be able to find a bottle opener or a storage rack that you can use on a gas grill. Before you purchase any attachments, you should make sure that you purchase something that is compatible with your grill. This will ensure that it works properly, avoiding any potential accidents. You will be able to check this by reading the product specifications.

Read more: How to Choose the Best Barbecue and Grill

Cooking In Different Weather Conditions

Not every day is bright and sunny. This means that you will need to learn how to cook in different weather conditions. For example, you might need to light the grill on a wet or windy day. There are several factors that can affect how challenging this will be. First, you might want to think about where you want to place the grill. For example, if you are placing it in a covered area with a strong windbreak, this might not be as much of a concern.

Generally, the biggest concern when trying to light gas is the wind. This might blow out matches and diffuse the gas, making it harder to light. In most cases, though, you should be able to get a gas burner lit fairly easily. When you choose to use charcoal, bad weather might be a bigger concern. If the charcoal gets wet, it will become much more difficult to light. It can also become slightly more difficult to light in windy conditions.


It’s also important that you find something that will be able to last for a long time. Thankfully, both of these grills are highly durable. However, there are a few areas that you might want to check to make sure that you are purchasing a high-quality device. First, look at the joints around the frame. When doing this, you should see that everything has been welded together properly. In addition, you should consider the type of materials that have been used. You should make sure that you get a solid type of metal, which won’t bend or break. If you have chosen a portable model, look at the wheels that they have chosen to use. They should be made from a solid material and firmly attached to the grill.


Finally, you should consider how you will store the grill when you aren’t using it. This will ensure that it doesn’t get damaged between uses. Thankfully, both types of grills are fairly easy to store properly. If you are planning to leave them in storage for a long time, you should make sure to prepare them properly. This means cleaning the grill thoroughly Any food scraps that you leave attached might attract animals. In addition, you might want to use a cover. This will prevent dust and dirt from getting into the grill and damaging important components.

Which Type Of Grill Should I Choose?

Which type of grill you should choose is often a personal decision, depending on the way that you prefer to cook and the type of food that you like to eat. To make it easier for you, we looked at several of the pros and cons associated with each of these options.

To summarize, gas grills will heat up faster. They are also easier to control, allowing you to adjust the temperature faster. They also tend to be easier to maintain. However, they aren’t as portable and tend to be more expensive to purchase. Depending on the type of model you select, you might need to have a professional come and it for you.

Read more: Best Portable Gas Grills

On the other hand, charcoal might be slightly harder to ignite and takes longer to get up to temperature. You will also need to monitor this more closely, adding more charcoal if you are cooking over a long period of time. However, these models tend to be the easiest to transport. Because they aren’t as complex as a gas grill, they are less likely to need replacement parts. However, the biggest advantage of cooking with charcoal is the amount of flavor that you can put into your food.

Regardless of which type you decide to choose, you should make sure to read plenty of online reviews before you make a purchase. These will provide clarity about some of the aspects of the product that might be a potential issue. By reading these, you will be able to distinguish between multiple types of grill, to find the best one to suit your needs. With so many different types of grill available, it can be hard to know which ones to focus on. For this reason, you might want to consider using this excellent online charcoal grill comparison guide. This will talk you through the different aspects of each product, to allow you to make a more informed decision.

Read more: How to Choose a Portable Natural Gas Grill


Gathering your friends and family for a dinner party is one of the best ways to strengthen your bonds. As we’ve seen, there are multiple differences between the two main types of grill; gas, and charcoal. Ultimately, the type of grill you select will depend on the type of occasions where you intend to use it. So, use this information to choose the best grill and enjoy the benefits that cooking outdoors can provide.

Updated on 2024-07-10 - Images from Amazon API. Logos are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. 1001Gardens is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

1 thought on “What To Choose: Gas Or Charcoal Grill?”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Exit mobile version